Hello and welcome to Onward’s weekly summary of research, events and opinion. We hope you enjoy it. If you do, tell your friends or donate to support our work.
Onward activity
This morning at 9am, we’ll be hosting Gary Neville to discuss Keeping the Game Beautiful and the fan-led review of football governance. Sign up here.
IN THE NEWS
Ruth Edwards MP, a member of Onward’s Getting to Zero Steering Board appeared in the West Bridgford Wire discussing Onward’s decarbonisation work.
EVENTS
This Thursday, 10th June: We will be hosting the last event in our LEVEL UP series, Making it Big: The future of UK manufacturing with Nadhim Zahawi, Minister for Business and Industry. Sign up here.
Next Tuesday: We are delighted to be joined by John Penrose MP, the Government’s Anti Corruption Champion, Andrew Griffith MP, Janet Williamson, Vanessa Knapp and Hywel Ball for a discussion on how the pandemic has redrawn the relationship between business and society, and what this means for corporate governance. Sign up here.
The agreement of the G7 to the dual principle of (a) a global minimum rate of corporate income tax and (b) the right of countries to tax the most profitable multinationals where their profit is generated, not headquartered, has divided opinion on the centre right.
While the Government has heralded the agreement as a "huge prize for British taxpayers" that will "level the playing field", there are some who argue that the agreement represents a loss of sovereignty and a rejection of competition. As this argument runs, the UK should be using its Brexit freedoms to become much more competitive to international business, rather than joining a rich country "cartel". In essence, we should be emulating Singapore, not acquiescing to become more like Germany.
The first problem with this argument is that the UK is only rejecting competition if it intends to reduce corporation taxes below the minimum effective tax level of 15%. The Chancellor has just announced plans to increase the headline rate to 25% in 2023 to fill the coronavirus-shaped black hole in the public finances. Foregoing those planned rises and reducing the current headline rate to 15% would create a fiscal gap of around £30 billion by 2025-26. That would be hard to defend when many corporates have generated bumper profits, at least in part because of the extraordinary economic underwriting by finance ministries during the pandemic, and there are noisy demands to spend more on kids' catch up, net zero and universal credit.
The second problem is that the deal does not envisage a "cartel" in any meaningful sense. It does not mean, for example, that every country will set a 15% or higher effective rate, only that multinational profits would be subject to a 15% minimum, even if they choose to book profits in a lower tax jurisdiction. So, the US Treasury would be able to levy an additional 10% corporate income tax on multinational profits booked in Ireland, where the effective rate is 5%. This suggests no loss of sovereignty, only a much reduced (and market-based) incentive to undercut the minimum given multinationals would be taxed at 15% anyway.
The third problem is that the deal should, in theory at least, make markets more efficient, not less. The last forty years has seen a growing tendency for large companies to register profits in opaque low tax jurisdictions and to structure their finances in highly complex and opaque ways. This has created a global industry in tax planning, profit shifting and avoidance that serves little economic purpose other than to reduce liabilities. The OECD, World Bank, and IMF have all warned of the distortive effects of profit shifting and base erosion, on rich and poor countries alike. Complexity and bureaucracy are the enemy of effective markets, after all.
It is for these reasons, as well as the growing public indignation over the taxes paid by digital giants, that successive Conservative chancellors have embraced multilateral diplomacy in their efforts to secure a sustainable corporate tax base. After a decade of glacial progress, Rishi Sunak's success within six months of a new US administration should be warmly welcomed.
Policy Bites
The Housing Secretary, Robert Jenrick, set out his plan to create First Homes: new-build properties with a 30% discount on the market price for first-time buyers. Link.
James Forsyth sets out the Government's options to achieve their goal to end the university boom years. Link.
London’s borough councils are overcoming Nimbyism and building more council homes. Link.
Quick Links
Corporate Europe: Europe used to be home to almost half of the world’s most valuable companies, what happened? Link.
Smoking Free: Oxfordshire County Council has announced its bid to become “smoke free” by 2025. Link.
Soulless Cities: Janice Turner argues that Britain’s cities have ditched social cohesion in favour of riches. Link.
Bedside Productivity: Employees who claim they’re more productive working from home might just be a case of wishful thinking. Link.
Thank you for reading
Thank you for taking the time to read this far.
If you liked the newsletter, please feel free to share with a friend or colleague.
Every other Friday, we also send out a Levelling Up Newsletter with pieces from MPs on the Levelling Up Taskforce. Sign up here.
If you found this in Spam, please drag it into your main inbox to train the algorithm.
If you like Onward’s work, consider donating as little as £2 a month.